Sibley’s Cases – DC Superior Court BOEE – Complaint

Title: SIBLEY, MONTGOMERY BLAIR Vs. DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS

Case #: 2012 CA 004892 B

Date Filed: 06/08/2012

Status: Closed

The complaint seeks declaratory judgment that the DC Board of Elections and Ethics (BOEE) has an obligation to determine the eligibility of President Obama, that the BOEE has a duty to respond to Sibley’s complaint, and a mandamus commanding the BOEE to respond to Sibley.

See also this article by the Huffington Post

Docket Date Description Messages
09/07/2012 Dismissed by Court Dismissed by Court
09/07/2012 Oral Ruling on Written Motion Entered on the Docket Oral Ruling on Defendant’s Written Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in Its Entirety (Granted) Entered on the Docket. AM

Participant(s): Judge ANTHONY C EPSTEIN

09/07/2012 Oral Ruling on Written Motion Entered on the Docket Oral Ruling on Defendant’s Written Motion for Sanctions Pursuant to Rule 11 (Denied without prejudice) Entered on the Docket

Participant(s): Judge ANTHONY C EPSTEIN

09/07/2012 Event Resulted: Event Resulted:

The following event: Initial Scheduling Conference-60 scheduled for 09/07/2012 at 9:30 am has been resulted as follows:Result: Scheduling Conference Hearing Held

Judge: EPSTEIN, ANTHONY C Location: Courtroom A-47 (Courtsmart) Plaintiff (pro se) and AAG Baker present. The court ruled on (2) pending motions: Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in Its Entirety Granted. Defendant’s Motion for Sanctions Pursuant to Rule 11 Denied without Prejudice. All reasons set forth orally by the court on the record. AM

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF); ; MELISSA L BAKER (Attorney) on behalf of DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant); Judge ANTHONY C EPSTEIN

08/20/2012 Reply to Opposition Filed Defendant’s Reply in Further Support of Its Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in its Entirety, and Its Motion for Sanctions Filed. submitted 08/20/2012 08:30. ms

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

08/17/2012 Opposition to Motion Filed: Plaintiff’s Statement of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss and for Rule 11 Sanctions Filed:

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF);

08/14/2012 Motion for Sanctions Filed Motion for Sanctions Pursuant to Rule 11. Filed. Submitted. 08/14/2012 16:03. ars.

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

08/14/2012 Motion to Dismiss Filed Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in Its Entirety. Filed. Submitted. 08/14/2012 15:59. ars.

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

08/01/2012 Order Filed Order Denying Motion to Deem that Defendant Waived Objection ot Sufficiency of Service. Signed by Judge A. Epstein on 08/01/12. Submitted. 08/01/2012 08:27. ncv.
08/01/2012 Order Denying Motion * Entered on the Docket Order Denying Motion to Deem that Defendant has Waived Objection to Service Entered on the Docket on August 1, 2012. Signed by J. Epstein in chambers on August 1, 2012 and efiled, eserved and mailed to all parties on August 1, 2012. cm
07/23/2012 Opposition to Motion Filed: Memoranum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Deem Defendant Has Waived Objection to Sufficiency of Service and for Early Scheduling Conference Filed. submitted 07/23/2012 14:33. ksc

Attorney: GRAHAM, GRACE (472878)

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

07/23/2012 Motion Filed: Plaintiff’s Motion To Deem That Defeendant Has Waived Objection To Sufficiency Of Service And For Early Scheduling Conference Filed

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF); Receipt: 230353 Date: 07/23/2012

07/19/2012 Order Filed Order Granting Motion asking the court to order Plaintiff to serve its counsel by Electronic Mail submitted 07/19/2012 08:43. ksc. signed by J/Epstein on 7/19/12
07/19/2012 Order Granting Motion * Entered on the Docket Order Granting Motion for Plaintiff to Serve by E-Mail Entered on the Docket on July 19, 2012. Signed by J. Epstein in chambers on July 19, 2012 and efiled, eserved and mailed to all parties on July 19, 2012. cm
07/17/2012 Opposition Filed: Plaintiff’s Statement of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Defendant’s Motion to Require Plaintiff to Serve Filings by Electronic Mail Filed

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF);

07/16/2012 Reply Filed: District of Columbia Board of Elections & Ethics Reply in Further Support of its Motion to Require Plaintiff to Serve Filings By Electronic Mail Filed. submitted 07/16/2012 10:51. ksc

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

07/10/2012 Motion Filed: Defendant District of Columbia Board of Elections and Ethics’ Motion to Require Plaintiff to Serve Filings by Electronic Mail Filed. Submitted 07/10/2012 14:51. ajm

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

07/09/2012 Order Filed Order Denying Sibley’s Motion to Compel Signed and Submitted by Judge Epstein on 07/09/2012 15:50. tw
07/09/2012 Order Denying Motion * Entered on the Docket Order Denying Motion to Expedite Entered on the Docket on July 9, 2012. Signed by J. Epstein in chambers on July 9, 2012 and efiled, eserved and mailed to all parties on July 9, 2012. cm
07/03/2012 Praecipe Filed: Praecipe and Request for Oral Argument Filed

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF);

07/03/2012 Praecipe Filed: Notice of Vacation Filed

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF);

06/13/2012 Praecipe Filed: Praecipe Filed:

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF);

06/13/2012 Motion Filed: Motion to Expedite Response to Complaint and Disposition Filed

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF); Receipt: 227242 Date: 06/13/2012

06/12/2012 Service Issued Issue Date: 06/12/2012

Service: Summons Issued

Method: Service Issued

Cost Per: $DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS

441 4th Street NW

Suite 250

WASHINGTON, DC 20001

Tracking No: 5000119387

06/11/2012 Praecipe to Enter Appearance Filed Praecipe to Enter Appearance of Melissa L. Baker as Attorney for the Defendant. Filed. Submitted. 06/11/2012 11:14. ncv.

Attorney: BAKER, MELISSA L (499368)

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA BOARD OF ELECTIONS AND ETHICS (Defendant);

06/08/2012 Alias Summons Filed Alias Summons Filed Receipt: 226887 Date: 06/08/2012
06/08/2012 Event Scheduled Event Scheduled

Event: Initial Scheduling Conference-60

Date: 09/07/2012 Time: 9:30 am

Judge: EPSTEIN, ANTHONY C Location: Courtroom A-47

06/08/2012 Complaint for Declaratory Judgment Filed Complaint for Declaratory Judgment Filed

Attorney: PRO SE (999999)

MONTGOMERY BLAIR SIBLEY (PLAINTIFF); Receipt: 226887 Date: 06/08/2012